Review: Ranking the 2025 Oscars best picture nominees
It’s finally time. After months of campaigning, premiering, magazine profiles, scandals and precursor awards, the 2025 Oscars will air live 6 p.m. Sunday on ABC and Hulu. From 207 movies eligible for best picture, which recognizes the most excellent film of the year, 10 are nominated but only one will take home the 2025 trophy. Unlike most of the other 22 categories, best picture is voted on a preferential ballot. Ballots are piled based on each voter’s first-choice selection. As votes are counted, the nominee with the fewest ballots had those votes redistributed to other piles based on second choices, third choices, fourth choices — and sometimes, fifth choices. While I don’t know how almost 10,000 voting members ranked their ballots, here’s what my own best picture Oscar ballot would look like if I were a voter. Click on the movie title for the trailer. 10. Emilia Pérez - directed by Jacques Audiard A crime thriller, a musical, an ode to Mexico and a depiction of a transgender woman, Emilia Pérez falls flat in every metric. Audiard’s bold and audacious approach won’t go unnoticed, but the film is overly directed and sloppily written to the point where he could only demonstrate tension right before the climax by doing a split screen. Pérez, as a character, is written so patronizingly that by the end she’s no longer a human, just a symbol or an icon. While the film has some technical merits — “El Mal” is actually a good sequence — and is anchored by Zoe Saldaña’s incredible performance, it’s overall not an effective story. (Stream it on Netflix) 9. A Complete Unknown - directed by James Mangold A Complete Unknown plays out as mysteriously as its title. Mangold has nothing more to say than that Bob Dylan tossed women away freely and used his talent as an excuse. It’s a constant poke of, “Isn’t he talented? Isn’t he great?” through Dylan’s songwriting, so much so that most of the film is just his songs. So many songs. There’s probably less than half an hour’s worth of dialogue. While the songs are great, the final movie is inarticulate, with a karaoke performance from Timothée Chalamet as Bob Dylan. Monica Barbaro, as Joan Baez, obliterates Chalamet’s Dylan in every scene. The MVP performance goes to Elle Fanning, who silently steals every minute of her limited screen time. (Rent with video-on-demand) 8. Wicked - directed by Jon Chu Wicked is quite an enjoyable, infectious weekend matinee, mainly when Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande are on screen together and during scenes showcasing Jonathan Bailey’s irresistible charm. Yet, Chu’s unwavering commitment to medium shots rarely allows two actors to demonstrate chemistry in one frame. When it goes for wide shots, “One Short Day,” for example, did not showcase body movement and couldn’t find its focal point between crowds, props and set pieces. Sometimes, Wicked takes full advantage of its beautiful production set and costume design, as in “Popular”. Most of the time, it is goofy and too heavy-handed in forcing emotions out of the audience, shown in “Defying Gravity”. So much social commentary and so many character motivations — all as deep as a puddle. (Rent on video-on-demand) 7. Dune: Part Two - directed by Denis Villeneuve Dune: Part Two is ambitious. Its sound mixing, set decorations and visual effects are hallmarks of epic filmmaking. It is also a disappointing antithesis to Villeneuve’s early projects, such as Incendies and Prisoners, which focus on layers of intricate character development. The clearest example of this is when Timothée Chalamet’s character, Paul, meets with the southern Freeman war council to galvanize the crowd. Loud style, little substance. Zendaya is equally as forgettable with a thinly drawn character, especially once Austin Butler — who clearly understands the somewhat silliness of this spectacle and played on that spectrum — appears. (Stream on Netflix, Max) 6. Nickel Boys - directed by RaMell Ross A lot of good things happened in Nickel Boys. The plot. The acting. The careful storytelling. Onto the not-so-good part: the bold first-perspective cinematography, which hinders the plot, the acting and the storytelling. We don’t get to experience the chemistry between characters during heavy-hitting exchanges or the characters’ expressions as they process what is happening to them. Instead, we see the actors acting at us, almost like a video game. In the few fleeting moments where Ross doesn’t stick with the tricky cinematography gimmick, he relies on repeating the narrative from the other’s perspective. Yet, the acting shines through and the thoughtful narrative rarely dims, both testaments to the film’s strengths. There are more good, beautiful moments than bad ones. You should still see it, because of what you need to learn here, to feel here. (Rent on video-on-demand) 5. Anora - directed by Sean Baker Anora is fun and decent. Love the soundtrack. Mikey Madison gives a “star is born” performance as the titular character. It has some explosive moments but dwells on issues from a very surface level and runs a touch too long. Baker’s social curiosity is enough for him to craft a fun film. But under the spotlight, there’s not much to see. His curiosity ends about 20 minutes into the film when Baker gets completely disinterested in telling the story of a sex worker and instead focuses on a screwball comedy. Anora, in the end, never had a true character. Sometimes she’s smart. At times she’s naive. Mostly, the men in this world are written more interestingly than her. (Rent on video-on-demand) 4. I’m Still Here - directed by Walter Salles Salles could’ve easily bogged I’m Still Here down with torture and political drama, considering its subject matter about the military dictatorship in Brazil in the early ’70s. Instead, with Fernanda Torres’ masterful performance, he focuses on home life before and after a mother’s arrest for inquiring about her husband’s abduction by the government. Life still happens, but there is now that underlying tension among family members and also those connected to the Paiva family. Long gone was the busting and lively music and art. Long gone were moments with the blue sky and the beach. What's left is a masterful depiction of how their home becomes a metaphor for what happened in Brazil: People lived there but wouldn’t fully acknowledge what was occurring. (Only in theaters) 3. Conclave - directed by Edward Berger All of Conclave is fiction, but you wouldn’t be able to tell because of how accurate and engaging the dialogue-driven story, costumes and production sets are — down to the wire. The acting is sublime, with Ralph Fiennes almost disappearing into the role. Berger did a wonderful job depicting the drama, gossip, conversations and all of the politics going on behind the scenes of electing a pope. It’s Mean Girls (Pope’s Version). One of the most beautiful movies to look at, and it’s tightly edited to shine a light on many worldwide issues: divisive political views, partisanship, war, the role of women and treatment of genders — all tied together by one huge twist. (Stream on Peacock) 2. The Brutalist - directed by Brady Corbet It’s hard to watch The Brutalist and not get swept away by its technical merits. In every frame, cut and sound bite, Corbet knows exactly what he wants to evoke from the audience and creates a cinematic achievement through his vision from the first frame and score. Even with those calculations, the film never loses a beat in its heartfelt approach to displaying the American Dream in the most brutally honest way imaginable. Its themes of suffering, resilience, resistance and addiction are all intricately woven together through an immigrant’s journey with amazing performances by Adrien Brody and Guy Pearce. (Rent on video-on-demand) 1. The Substance - directed by Coralie Fargeat Bold, audacious and relentless — I’ve raved far too much about The Substance. From a career-best, haunting performance by Demi Moore to the gutsy vision of Fargeat, the movie is a once-in-a-lifetime experience. (Stream on Mubi) @DangHLe news-editor.shorthorn@uta.edu